Heka vs Honeygain: your work is worth more than your bandwidth
Heka · updated
Honeygain and Heka make the same pitch: install an app, let it run in the background, get paid. Both are real, both pay actual money, and you can even run both at once. The difference is what each one sells — and that difference decides how much ends up in your pocket.
Honeygain resells your unused internet connection. Heka sells anonymized recordings of the work you already do on your Mac. One is a commodity priced by the gigabyte; the other is training data AI companies can barely buy anywhere.
Choose Heka
Choose Heka if you work on a Mac most days and want your earnings tied to your own work sessions instead of network demand.
Choose Honeygain
Choose Honeygain if you have spare phones or non-Mac devices on unlimited data — or run it alongside Heka, since the two don't compete for the same resource.
Side by side
| Heka | Honeygain | |
|---|---|---|
| What it sells | Anonymized recordings of your work sessions, as AI training data | Your unused bandwidth, routed to businesses through your connection |
| How you earn | Per session of real work in everyday apps | Per GB shared — about $0.10 per GB at Honeygain's published rate |
| Typical month | Most active users cover a few subscriptions a month | A few dollars per device; a public 90-day test averaged ~$2.40 per device |
| Minimum payout | $10, cash out any time | $20 via PayPal (crypto available sooner) |
| Platforms | macOS (menu-bar app) | Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS |
| Privacy trade | Screen data anonymized on-device; messaging apps never captured | Third-party traffic exits through your home IP address |
| Effort | None on top of your normal workday | None — earns even while the device sits idle |
| Getting in | Waitlist, or an invite code from an existing user | Open signup |
Why bandwidth pays cents
Residential bandwidth is a commodity. Honeygain's own materials price it at roughly $0.10 per shared gigabyte, and independent long-term tests land on a few dollars per device per month for most casual users. Reviews that tracked the space across years also note per-GB rates drifting down as more people plug in — supply keeps growing, demand doesn't.
Recordings of real computer work are the opposite: AI companies need thousands of hours of real workflows to train computer-use agents, and almost none of it exists for sale. That scarcity is why a work session is worth more than a gigabyte, and it's the entire reason Heka can pay more for a single working Mac than bandwidth apps pay for a whole household of devices.
Privacy: proxy exit vs on-device anonymization
Honeygain's model routes other companies' traffic through your home IP address. The company states it doesn't access your personal data, but the product is your connection itself — worth checking your ISP's terms on sharing it.
Heka records your screen while you work, which sounds scarier — so the guardrails are stricter. Everything is anonymized on your Mac before upload: names, emails, and keys are replaced on-device. Messaging apps are never captured, you can pause from the menu bar, exclude apps entirely, and request deletion of anything already uploaded. Nothing leaves your Mac raw, and no third-party traffic ever flows through your connection.
Where Honeygain wins
Honeygain runs on nearly everything — old Android phones, Windows machines, Linux boxes — and earns even while a device sits idle overnight. It has operated since 2019 and claims over 60 million registered users, so the track record is long. Heka is macOS-only, pays for real work sessions rather than idle time, and access currently moves through a waitlist.
If you have a drawer of spare devices on unlimited data, Honeygain monetizes them and Heka doesn't. The honest play many people land on: Honeygain on the spare devices, Heka on the Mac you actually work on.
Frequently asked questions
- Can I run Heka and Honeygain at the same time?
- Yes. They don't compete for the same resource — Honeygain shares your internet connection, while Heka records and anonymizes your work sessions. Running both on the same Mac is fine, and many people in the passive-income community stack apps this way.
- Is Honeygain legit?
- Yes — it has paid users since 2019 and publishes its rates. The catch is scale, not honesty: at roughly $0.10 per shared GB, most single devices earn a few dollars a month, and the $20 PayPal minimum can take months to reach.
- Why does Heka pay more per device than bandwidth apps?
- Because of what's being sold. Bandwidth is a commodity with ever-growing supply, so the per-GB price is low and falling. Anonymized recordings of real computer work are scarce — AI companies need thousands of hours to train computer-use agents and can barely buy any — so a real work session is worth far more than a gigabyte of traffic.
- Does Heka share my internet connection like Honeygain does?
- No. Heka never routes third-party traffic through your connection and doesn't touch your bandwidth. It records your screen during work sessions, anonymizes everything on-device — names, emails, and keys are replaced before upload — and never captures messaging apps.
- What exactly does Heka record?
- Your screen and interactions during work sessions, anonymized on your Mac before anything uploads — names, emails, keys and other personal data get replaced on-device. Messaging apps are excluded at the capture level, so your chats are never recorded in the first place, and nothing ever leaves the machine raw.
Sources
More comparisons
Heka pays you for the work you already do on your Mac. Get early access.